
Reach for this book when your middle schooler is navigating the dizzying, often embarrassing highs and lows of a first big crush or when friendship dynamics are shifting as everyone starts 'growing up' at different speeds. It is an honest and humorous look at the social hierarchy of middle school through the eyes of two fiercely independent best friends. Mikey and Margalo are the self-titled 'Bad Girls' who usually do not care about being popular, but everything changes when Mikey falls head over heels for a handsome classmate. As Mikey tries on new identities and Margalo navigates her own secret feelings, the story explores themes of self-confidence, loyalty, and the fear of being left behind. Parents will appreciate the realistic, secular approach to the pre-teen experience that avoids being overly preachy or saccharine.
Focuses on crushes, flirting, and the desire for first kisses.
The book deals with pre-teen social pressure and the insecurity of changing bodies/interests in a secular, realistic way. There are no major tragedies, only the 'micro-tragedies' of middle school social life. The resolution is realistic: not everyone gets the guy, but the friendship remains intact.
A 6th or 7th grader who feels like an outsider and is starting to notice that 'everyone' is talking about dating. It's perfect for the kid who values their best friend above all else but feels the tug of typical teenage interests.
Read cold. No major warnings needed. Parents might want to discuss Mikey's 'I LOVE ME' shirt as a conversation starter about self-esteem versus vanity. A parent might see their child suddenly change their clothing style, start acting 'fake' to impress someone, or see a rift forming between two formerly inseparable best friends.
Younger readers (10) will find Mikey's antics hilarious and perhaps a bit cringey. Older readers (13-14) will recognize the deeper poignancy of Margalo’s loneliness and the fear that your best friend is outgrowing you.
Unlike many 'crush' books, this focuses heavily on the intellectual and platonic bond between two girls. Cynthia Voigt writes with a sharp, unsentimental wit that treats pre-teen girls as complex thinkers rather than just victims of hormones.
Mikey Elsinger, usually a confident rebel, falls for the gorgeous Shawn Macavity. She abandons her 'Bad Girl' persona for a makeover and over-the-top romantic gestures. Meanwhile, her best friend Margalo plays the voice of reason while secretly harboring her own romantic daydreams. The plot centers on the tension between maintaining one's identity and the desire to be noticed by a crush.
This overview was generated by AI based on the book's content and reviews, and may not capture every nuance.
Your experience helps other parents find the right book.
Sign in to write a review