
Reach for this book when your teenager is grappling with the heavy weight of family expectations or the lingering trauma of a community crisis that others seem ready to move past. Set in the somber aftermath of a great war against a dark god, it follows sixteen-year-old Hallie and her sister as they fight to keep their farm alive while waiting for a soldier who may never return. It is a deeply atmospheric exploration of grief, resilience, and the internal monsters we face when the external ones have supposedly been defeated. Parents will appreciate the sophisticated, poetic prose that treats adolescent emotions with the gravity they deserve. While the setting is a fantasy world filled with eerie creatures, the core of the story is grounded in the realistic struggle of two sisters navigating financial hardship and the slow reveal of painful family secrets. It is an ideal choice for mature teens who prefer character-driven, lyrical stories over fast-paced action, offering a safe space to discuss how we carry on when life feels 'barely comprehensible.'
Pervasive themes of grief, loss of family members, and the struggle of poverty.
Eerie, supernatural 'Things' and monsters create a lingering sense of dread and tension.
Depictions of the physical toll of war and occasional encounters with dangerous creatures.
The book deals with the aftermath of war, PTSD (represented both through the veteran character and the sisters' trauma), and the grief of missing loved ones. The approach is metaphorical and deeply psychological, rooted in a secular but folklore-heavy fantasy world. The resolution is realistic and hard-won rather than a fairy-tale ending.
A thoughtful, introspective teenager (14+) who enjoys 'quiet' fantasy. This is for the student who feels older than their peers or the reader who appreciates the beauty in sad, 'ugly' truths and complex sibling dynamics.
The prose is dense and highly metaphorical; parents should be aware that this is a 'slow burn' that requires focus. There are scenes of body-horror-adjacent monster encounters and depictions of the physical and mental scars of war. A parent might see their teen becoming increasingly withdrawn or frustrated by 'adult' responsibilities and chores, or perhaps noticing their child struggling with a lack of closure after a personal or community loss.
Younger teens will focus on the 'monsters' and the survival aspect of the farm. Older teens and adults will connect with the themes of generational trauma, the burden of inheritance, and the nuanced breakdown of the sisterly bond.
Unlike many YA fantasies that focus on the 'chosen one' winning the war, Bobet focuses on the 'leftovers': the people who have to clean up the mess and keep living after the heroes have gone home.
In the wake of a war against the Wicked God Southward, Hallie and her sister Marthe are left to maintain their failing farm while waiting for Marthe's husband, Thom, to return. When they hire a scarred veteran to help with the labor, Hallie begins to realize that the 'victory' everyone celebrates is hollow. As strange, monstrous 'Things' begin to creep across the landscape, Hallie must navigate her fractured relationship with her sister and the terrifying realization that the war hasn't ended: it has simply changed shape.
This overview was generated by AI based on the book's content and reviews, and may not capture every nuance.
Your experience helps other parents find the right book.
Sign in to write a review