
Reach for this book when your older teenager is grappling with the disillusionment that comes when a trusted mentor or adult role model falls from grace. It is a sophisticated story for mature readers that explores the messy intersection of idolization, betrayal, and the journey toward personal agency. After a confusing and inappropriate advance from a beloved female mentor, sixteen-year-old Polly O'Keefe travels to Greece and Cyprus to find herself and process her trauma. The novel deals honestly with themes of sexual identity, the pain of terminal illness, and the complex process of forgiving someone while still holding them accountable. It is a profound choice for a teen who feels isolated by a secret or a difficult experience, offering a realistic look at how one navigates the gray areas of human relationships and emerges with a stronger sense of self.
Depicts a sexual encounter between teens and an inappropriate advance from an adult to a teen.
Themes of terminal illness, death, and the loss of a close friendship.
Significant scenes involving heavy drinking and alcoholism.
Terminal illness (Max is dying), alcoholism and heavy drinking (the catalyst for the incident), sexual harassment and unwanted advances from a trusted adult mentor, and teen sexual activity.
A mature teenager (16 plus) who is navigating the difficult transition from childhood idolization of adults to seeing them as flawed, sometimes harmful individuals. It is particularly resonant for those who have experienced a breach of trust by a mentor.
Parents should preview the pivotal flashback scene where Max makes an advance on Polly while intoxicated, as well as Polly’s subsequent encounter with Renny. These scenes are essential for discussing consent and the impact of adult behavior on teen choices. A parent may notice their teen suddenly withdrawing from a previously beloved extracurricular activity or adult mentor without a clear explanation, or showing signs of deep confusion regarding boundaries.
Younger teens (13-14) may find the non-linear structure and the moral ambiguity of Max’s actions distressing or difficult to parse. Older teens (17-18) will likely appreciate the nuanced exploration of forgiveness and the reality that people we love can cause us profound harm.
Unlike many YA novels that treat betrayal as a black and white issue, L’Engle explores the agonizing gray area of loving someone who has failed you, while maintaining a clear stance that the adult is responsible for the breach of safety.
Sixteen year old Polly O'Keefe travels to Greece and Cyprus to work at a literary conference, using the distance to process a traumatic rupture with her mentor, Max. Back on Benne Seed Island, Max (a lesbian artist in a long term partnership with a woman named Ursula) had become Polly’s primary intellectual influence. However, after a night of heavy drinking, the terminally ill Max made a confusing and unwanted sexual advance toward Polly. This betrayal led Polly to a brief, semi-consensual sexual encounter with a peer, Renny, fueled by her distress. The narrative follows Polly’s attempts to reconcile her love for her mentor with this violation of trust while exploring her own burgeoning independence.
This overview was generated by AI based on the book's content and reviews, and may not capture every nuance.
Your experience helps other parents find the right book.
Sign in to write a review